LiveThursday · 19 November 2026Vol. VIII · No. 323
Bangalore
26°C · Partly cloudy26°C
Thu, 19 Nov
Latest
Local

Dual reporting structures built into the new police system in Bengaluru, raise concerns

Concerns rise over Bengaluru Police's five-commissionerate restructure causing dual reporting lines and potential command conflicts.

Speaking to The Hindu, senior officers who have previously held the position of Traffic DCPs in the city said the new hierarchy could create complications in obtaining approvals, planning, and coordinating with civic bodies

Updated - November 19, 2026 09:18 am IST - Bengaluru

R. Hithendra, the 40th police chief of Bengaluru city, with Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar after assuming charge, in Bengaluru on Wednesday. | Photo Credit: SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT

The restructuring of Bengaluru City Police into five commissionerates with a Chief Commissioner has several dual reporting structures built into it, which could potentially cause administrative issues, several senior police officials have flagged, on Wednesday following the government order on the restructuring. They have pointed out that hierarchy and chain of command was key in the police and that was not clear in the new organisational structure, even as roles are also yet to be defined properly.

For instance, the five police commissioners will directly report to the Director-General and Inspector-General of Police (DG&IGP), Karnataka, the order says, but while defining the role of the Chief Commissioner it said he would supervise the five commissioners. The order even acknowledges the confusion and says any clarification about mutual powers and functions of the Chief Commissioner of Police and Commissioners of Police of the five commissionerates will be clarified by the government for their smooth functioning. While the chain of command for the Law and Order functions of the police in the city remains clear, both traffic and crime seem to be marred by dual reporting structures that can cause confusion and put the lower bureaucracy under stress over conflicting orders and hamper a coherent strategy.

For the traffic police, the additional layer has created confusion for Deputy Commissioners of Police (DCPs), as they will now have to report to both the local commissioners and the Commissioner of Police (Traffic). Speaking to The Hindu, senior officers who have previously held the position of Traffic DCPs in the city said the new hierarchy could create complications in obtaining approvals, planning, and coordinating with civic bodies.

Currently, all planning functions of the Bengaluru Traffic Police fall under the ambit of the Joint Commissioner of Police. However, while the new order places the responsibility for planning city traffic with the Commissioner of Police (Traffic), there is no clarity on which aspects the Traffic DCPs will have to report to the local commissioners.

While each commissionerate has a DCP (Crime), there is also an Additional Commissioner (Anti-Rowdy Squad) at the city level, both of which are expected to replace the erstwhile Central Crime Branch. Hemanth M. Nimbalkar has also been tasked with “supervising crime control” across the city. This has also created a dual reporting structure for crime.

Dual reporting structures built into the new police system in Bengaluru, raise concerns

A senior police officer said the hierarchy could create pressure, with its effects cascading down to inspectors and lower-ranking officers.“For instance, if we have a case in hand and one officer suggests one method of investigation and another suggests a different one, which of the two should the DCP choose? This could further percolate down to the inspector if the pressure mounts on the DCP,” the officer explained.

Even local-level planning, including crime monitoring and patrolling strategies, could be affected by such conflicts, leading to a substantial burden on officers and delays in implementing plans, the officer said.

Published - November 19, 2026 12:30 am IST

Terms & conditions | Institutional Subscriber

Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.

Related in Local

Heritage walk at Bengaluru’s Someshwara temple celebrates local history
Local

Heritage walk at Bengaluru’s Someshwara temple celebrates local history

Chai with History at Bengaluru’s Someshwara Swamy temple

The Hindu — Bangalore19 Nov
New 19.2-km elevated corridor from Ulsoor to Bagalur proposed to ease airport traffic
Local

New 19.2-km elevated corridor from Ulsoor to Bagalur proposed to ease airport traffic

Plan for a 19.3-km elevated corridor from Ulsoor to Bagalur to ease Bengaluru airport traffic, modeled on Hebbal flyover.

The Hindu — Bangalore18 Nov
Bengaluru is India’s AI, start-up capital; city captures 47% of national venture funding: Report
Local

Bengaluru is India’s AI, start-up capital; city captures 47% of national venture funding: Report

Bengaluru leads India’s AI and unicorn growth, attracting 36.3% native AI funding and 57 unicorns worth $211B, driving a global deep-tech startup boom.

The Hindu — Bangalore18 Nov
Seven police stations added, four new divisions created
Local

Seven police stations added, four new divisions created

Bengaluru City Police adds four divisions and brings seven rural stations into city limits, restructuring divisions and boosting urban staffing.

The Hindu — Bangalore18 Nov
Commonwealth meet focuses on women’s leadership, tech-driven challenges, destigmatising menopause
Local

Commonwealth meet focuses on women’s leadership, tech-driven challenges, destigmatising menopause

The two-day Commonwealth Women Parliamentarians (CWP) India Region meet in Bengaluru concluded on Wednesday, with discussions focused on women’s leadership, technology-driven challenges and destigmatising menopause.

The Hindu — Bangalore18 Nov
Karnataka: 15 years after being rescued from a brick kiln in Chickballapur, bonded labour survivor gets ₹7 lakh compensation
Local

Karnataka: 15 years after being rescued from a brick kiln in Chickballapur, bonded labour survivor gets ₹7 lakh compensation

Survivor of bonded labor finally awarded ₹7 lakh compensation by DLSA, reflecting long legal battles and trauma recovery.

The Hindu — Bangalore18 Nov

Latest Across Vijaya Chronicle

Cyclone 'Akvan' LIVE updates: Severe cyclonic storm moves northwards; nearly 50,000 evacuated in Odisha
Politics

Cyclone 'Akvan' LIVE updates: Severe cyclonic storm moves northwards; nearly 50,000 evacuated in Odisha

Cyclone Akvan Live Updates: Follow The Hindu’s live blog for the latest updates as the severe cyclonic storm moves over the Bay of Bengal, with landfall expected along the Andhra Pradesh-Odisha coast by November 20. Get the latest updates on cyclone preparedness and evacuation me

The Hindu19 Nov
Census 2027: ‘Other’ religions list made predictive text, over 200 entries from earlier list dropped
Politics

Census 2027: ‘Other’ religions list made predictive text, over 200 entries from earlier list dropped

Census 2027 shows predictive text for “Other” religions with 76 entries after dropping over 200 previously listed options, sparking integrity concerns.

The Hindu19 Nov
PM Modi pays tribute to former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi on her birth anniversary
Crime

PM Modi pays tribute to former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi on her birth anniversary

Indira Gandhi, India's first woman Prime Minister, was born on November 19, 1917, in Allahabad, now Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh. | India News

Hindustan Times19 Nov
BJP turns to Mathura temple issue amid cadre unease, allies’ pressure
Politics

BJP turns to Mathura temple issue amid cadre unease, allies’ pressure

BJP shifts focus to Mathura Krishna temple amid cadre unease and alliance seat-sharing pressures ahead of UP polls.

The Hindu19 Nov
Why Ukraine keeps targeting the Kerch Bridge
Politics

Why Ukraine keeps targeting the Kerch Bridge

Ukraine targets the Kerch Bridge repeatedly, highlighting strategic symbolism and ongoing impact on Russia’s supply routes and Crimea relations.

The Hindu19 Nov
Why has the INDIA bloc posed 48 questions to the Election Commission over SIR?
Politics

Why has the INDIA bloc posed 48 questions to the Election Commission over SIR?

India bloc seeks transparency on Election Commission's SIR decisions by demanding 48 interrogatories to reveal internal approval, procedure, and records.

The Hindu19 Nov