LiveTuesday · 17 November 2026Vol. VIII · No. 321
Bangalore
28°C · Mostly clear28°C
Tue, 17 Nov
Latest
Business

Instagram and Facebook could change forever if Meta loses child privacy trial

US states are suing the social media giant to force an overhaul of its platforms for young users.

Instagram and Facebook could change forever if Meta loses child privacy trial

Meta has been hit with successive losses in court over how its platforms have targeted and harmed young users, but a jury trial set to begin on Tuesday may pose the biggest threat yet to its operations.

The trial stems from a lawsuit filed in 2023 by 30 US states, including California and New York, in which they claim numerous violations of federal and state privacy laws for children.

Not only are the states seeking upwards of $1 trillion, external from Meta, they are demanding it make changes to Instagram and Facebook, including ending "like" counts and infinite scroll.

Should Meta ultimately lose a case of this scale, it could force fundamental changes to the way young people experience social media.

The states suing Meta are asking for many more changes to the way Instagram and Facebook operate for young people, too.

implement a process of parental verification for teenage users

change its "dopamine-manipulating recommendation algorithms"

remove many image filters that change one's appearance in photos

end autoplay of video content

prohibit the creation of multiple accounts

end disappearing or "ephemeral" posts, such as Instagram Stories

All of these features are central to the current user experience on Meta's platforms.

These features are also designed to keep users, including teenagers and children, on the platforms as often and for as long as possible, the states contend. They claim Meta even makes it difficult for young people to use the platform less, through things like frequent notifications designed to get young people back on the apps.

By allegedly targeting child users, Meta "chose to exploit" young people in order to hook them on its platforms, so it could grow its user base and expand its business. Today, Meta's value on the stock market is about $1.5tn.

Meta has consistently denied such claims.

"We strongly disagree with these allegations and are confident the evidence will show our longstanding commitment to supporting young people," a company spokeswoman said in a statement.

The states are putting their claims to Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, a chief federal judge in California. She was the judge in the high-profile Elon Musk v Sam Altman trial and has built a reputation from the bench over the course of nearly 20 years for being incisive and direct.

Social media turned 'public nuisance'

In a recent ruling against Meta, a judge in New Mexico fined the company a collective $942m and ordered it to make changes similar to those that the additional states are now demanding.

Judge Bryan Biedscheid's ordered changes include the elimination on Instagram and Facebook of like counts for users younger than 18, a ban on teenagers sending or receiving nudity through the platforms, and limiting push notifications from the apps to certain hours of the day.

The judge also declared Meta a "public nuisance" akin to a factory that was polluting the air people breathe, causing "harmful effects" that impacted an entire population. Meta said it would appeal against the ruling.

While Judge Biedscheid's order only demands Meta make changes in New Mexico, should the 30 states prevail in their separate lawsuit against Meta, it would almost certainly need to enact platform changes across the US.

The states involved in the lawsuit represent nearly two-thirds of the country's population.

If Meta did enact such changes, it would mark a significant alteration to the experience of its platforms.

"Like" counts, for instance, have been part of Meta since its early years, when it was still called Facebook and that was its only platform.

Today, likes are omnipresent on social media platforms. It is the main way in which people engage with text, photos and videos they see online.

Yet, likes are increasingly viewed as a way to foster negative feelings, particularly among young people.

Kaley, a young woman who prevailed in her lawsuit against Meta earlier this year, described during court testimony how she created dozens of accounts on YouTube and Instagram.

She would use the system of accounts to create likes on her own posts, hoping to drive engagement with other users and her own feelings of validation and self-worth. Kaley was only nine years old at the time. She said she remembered feeling depressed, something she was later diagnosed with, aged 10.

Research over the last several years has shown that engagement metrics such as like counts can drive feelings of rejection and depression, external in teenagers.

In the states' lawsuit against Meta, in which the company said it has handed over more than 2 million documents, lawyers pointed to Meta's own research that showed like counts drove "social comparison", or the mental act of marking one's self worth against images of someone else.

Related in Business

Latest Across Vijaya Chronicle

ASEAN Summit LIVE updates: PM Modi to participate in ASEAN-India Summit; Quad meeting likely after Trump arrives
Politics

ASEAN Summit LIVE updates: PM Modi to participate in ASEAN-India Summit; Quad meeting likely after Trump arrives

PM Modi set to attend 23rd ASEAN-India and 21st East Asia Summits in Manila today. Follow The Hindu LIVE updates as India strengthens its Act East Policy ties.

The Hindu17 Nov
Census 2027 turning out to be farce: Congress
Politics

Census 2027 turning out to be farce: Congress

Congress claims Census 2027 is a farce with grave implications, citing data glitches and dubious intent in India's census process.

The Hindu17 Nov
BJP calls Sonia Gandhi’s memoir launch a ‘self-goal’, says it exposes Congress’ past misdeeds
Politics

BJP calls Sonia Gandhi’s memoir launch a ‘self-goal’, says it exposes Congress’ past misdeeds

BJP hails Sonia Gandhi’s memoir launch as a self-goal, accusing it of sanitizing Congress’ past misdeeds ahead of elections.

The Hindu17 Nov
‘Flagrant non-compliance’: Activists say ECI’s Nov 6 directive not being followed
Crime

‘Flagrant non-compliance’: Activists say ECI’s Nov 6 directive not being followed

In a letter to ECI, Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri said accused election officials in Delhi of “flagrant non-compliance” with the November 6 directions. | India News

Hindustan Times17 Nov
Eight killed, 26 injured as bus plunges into 100-metre gorge in Uttarakhand's Tehri Garhwal
Politics

Eight killed, 26 injured as bus plunges into 100-metre gorge in Uttarakhand's Tehri Garhwal

Eight killed, 26 injured as a passenger bus fell into a 100-metre gorge near Gular bridge in Tehri Garhwal, Uttarakhand.

The Hindu17 Nov
Nikhara drive: Cases registered against 275 traders for cheating on weights in Karnataka
Politics

Nikhara drive: Cases registered against 275 traders for cheating on weights in Karnataka

Continuing the ‘Nikhara’ drive, officials from the Department of Food, Civil Supplies, Consumer Affairs, and Legal Metrology conducted simultaneous inspections across nine major Agricultural Produce Markets (APMCs) in the State on Monday morning.

The Hindu17 Nov