LiveSaturday · 14 November 2026Vol. VIII · No. 318
Bangalore
29°C · Overcast29°C
Sat, 14 Nov
Latest
Crime

‘Sincerely regret, apologise’: Bar Council chief to students after CJI Kant's rap amid NALSAR row

“If anything connected with the controversy has hurt the feelings of our students, I sincerely apologise," Bar Council Chairman Manan Kumar Mishra said. | India News

“If anything connected with the controversy has hurt the feelings of our students, I sincerely apologise," Bar Council Chairman Manan Kumar Mishra said.

A day after Chief Justice of India Surya Kant came down hard on the Bar Council of India (BCI) for its intervention in the NALSAR University of Law enrolment controversy, BCI chairman Manan Kumar Mishra on Saturday apologised to the law students, saying he sincerely regretted if anything connected with the controversy, including his words or letter, had hurt their feelings.

In an Independence Day letter addressed to “my dear young friends”, Mishra said the developments of the past few days had caused “concern and anguish” among a section of the student community and acknowledged that whenever students felt hurt or aggrieved, their concerns deserved to be heard “with patience, sensitivity and respect”.

“If anything connected with the present controversy, any of my words, or letter, has hurt the feelings of our law students, I sincerely regret and apologise for the same,” Mishra said.

“There should be no hesitation in saying so. An expression of regret is not a matter of prestige or ego. It is simply an acknowledgment that the feelings and concerns of our students matter,” he added.

Also Read | 'Between me and students': CJI Surya Kant slams Bar Council move against protesters

The apology comes a day after CJI Kant told BCI that it had “no business” interfering in the NALSAR controversy and made it clear that students had a right to protest so long as their protests remained lawful and peaceful.

The bench, headed by CJI Kant and comprising justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, had also restrained the BCI and all state bar councils from pursuing any punitive or criminal action against students and faculty of national law universities or other universities in connection with the controversy.

The court’s intervention followed the BCI’s dramatic reversal over the enrolment of the 2026 graduating batch of NALSAR, Hyderabad. The council on Thursday initially directed all state bar councils not to enrol the students “till further orders”. Hours later, it withdrew the freeze but retained an inquiry into allegations that some teachers and outsiders had instigated or misled students. On Friday, Mishra announced that the proceedings against the entire 2026 batch were being closed.

Also Read | BCI halts enrolment of NALSAR 2026 graduates amid row over CJI Surya Kant in convocation, withdraws move later

The latest letter goes further to put an end to the controversy, with Mishra stressing that law students must remain free to form their own views.

‘Sincerely regret, apologise’: Bar Council chief to students after CJI Kant's rap amid NALSAR row

“Our law students, particularly those studying in the National Law Universities and other leading Centres of Legal Education, are among the most informed and discerning young citizens of the country,” Mishra said. He added that they study the Constitution, the Rule of Law, fairness and the importance of hearing all sides before reaching a conclusion and “do not require anyone to decide for them”.

Mishra also acknowledged the importance of dissent, saying peaceful disagreement, questioning and protest were “important features of a constitutional democracy” and that students “must always remain free to express their views”.

Also Read | Who is Manan Kumar Mishra? Bar Council Chair at centre of CJP's 'isteefa do' post, NALSAR row

At the same time, he said issues could be reconsidered when further facts or clarifications emerged. “There is no inconsistency between expressing a genuine grievance and thereafter fairly considering a clarification,” he said.

The BCI chairman also addressed the question of the NALSAR convocation, saying the decision whether to attend must ultimately remain with the students themselves. “No student should be compelled to attend, and no student should feel compelled to abstain,” he said, while appealing to them to take the decision independently after considering the matter in its entirety.

The controversy erupted after a section of NALSAR students objected to CJI Kant being invited as chief guest for their convocation this year.

Also Read | NALSAR student body condemns BCI over withdrawn enrolment order, seeks apology from chief

The students had cited remarks made by CJI Kant during proceedings concerning alleged police excesses during student protests in Delhi and questioned whether his invitation was consistent with NALSAR’s commitment to constitutional rights, access to justice and reasoned engagement with grievances.

The BCI had subsequently sought an authenticated report from NALSAR identifying those who had initiated, organised, coordinated or mobilised the campaign opposing the CJI’s participation in the convocation.

Related in Crime

'Turbulence world is going through could last a few years': S Jaishankar at HTLS 2026
Crime

'Turbulence world is going through could last a few years': S Jaishankar at HTLS 2026

Speaking at HTLS 2026, Jaishankar said the world order today was navigating stormy seas amid multiple conflicts, frictions and uncertainties. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
PM Modi pays tribute to Jawaharlal Nehru on his 137th birth anniversary
Crime

PM Modi pays tribute to Jawaharlal Nehru on his 137th birth anniversary

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh also paid tribute to the country's first Prime Minister, recalling his contribution to India's freedom struggle. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
Nitish Kumar meets union minister Lalan Singh hours after his meeting with Bihar CM Samrat Choudhary
Crime

Nitish Kumar meets union minister Lalan Singh hours after his meeting with Bihar CM Samrat Choudhary

The meetings took place on the day CM Choudhary announced that the Kachhi Dargah–Raghopur–Bidupur six-lane bridge would be named after Nitish Kumar. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
HT morning news brief November 14: US briefly grounds flights; Delhi records ‘very poor’ AQI
Crime

HT morning news brief November 14: US briefly grounds flights; Delhi records ‘very poor’ AQI

Here is a quick roundup of the major headlines in national and international affairs, sports, and entertainment. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
Sun, faith, and the Ganga: Bihar gears up for the sacred rhythm of Chhath
Crime

Sun, faith, and the Ganga: Bihar gears up for the sacred rhythm of Chhath

Chhath is defined by quiet endurance, ecological harmony, and a profound egalitarian spirit where every devotee stands equal in knee-deep water. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
NHRC notice to education ministry over complaint related to 'Veer Baal Diwas' events in schools
Crime

NHRC notice to education ministry over complaint related to 'Veer Baal Diwas' events in schools

NHRC notice to education ministry over complaint related to 'Veer Baal Diwas' events in schools | India News

Hindustan Times13 Nov

Latest Across Vijaya Chronicle