LiveThursday · 19 November 2026Vol. VIII · No. 323
Bangalore
26°C · Overcast26°C
Thu, 19 Nov
Latest
Politics

Supreme Court notice to ECI, Centre on plea challenging decisions taken by CEC-led poll panel

Supreme Court seeks responses from ECI and Centre after petitions alleging unilateral CEC-led decisions and immunity concerns in India’s election governance.

The Bench said the decisions of the Election Commission have to be either unanimous or by majority and that it presumed that this is how all decisions were taken

Updated - October 05, 2026 02:44 pm IST - New Delhi

Supreme Court of India. File | Photo Credit: S. Subramanium

The Supreme Court on Monday (October 5, 2026) issued notice to the Election Commission (ECI) and the Centre seeking responses in a week on a plea challenging the manner in which the poll panel led by the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar took decisions allegedly without the approval of two Election Commissioners.

Also Read: Protest against CEC Gyanesh Kumar updated on October 5

A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana took note of the submissions of senior advocate Vikas Singh and issued the notice.

The Bench said the decisions of the Election Commission have to be either unanimous or by majority, and that it presumed that this is how all decisions were taken.

Also Read: When Election Commission was rocked by internal disputes | Explained

The PIL, filed by Patna resident Rakesh Kumar Singh, urged the top court to determine whether Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Kumar has been individually exercising powers that legally belong to the ECI as a whole, and, if so, to declare those actions unauthorised and take appropriate legal action.

Senior advocate Vikas Singh for petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh said the 2023 Act expands the ambit of immunity from legal action in favour of the CEC. “The credibility of the ECI is so undermined that citizens are not feeling safe,” said the senior advocate. He said that only the procedure for the transaction of business within the Election Commission should be unanimous, but decisions can be taken by majority.

Supreme Court notice to ECI, Centre on plea challenging decisions taken by CEC-led poll panel

Justice J. Joymalya Bagchi said that even judges are not given the protection given to the CEC in Section 16 of the 2023 Act. Under Section 16, the CEC is protected from legal action even after demitting office.

Senior advocate Vikas Singh urged the immediate suspension of the CEC, suggesting that the other two Election Commissioners fill in. Judge Bagchi, in response, said that petitions have to be filed with an eye on the working of the Constitution.

Mr. Singh urged interim relief, or he warned that the “country will burn”. “Till the Supreme Court finally decides, let the Election Commission take decisions unanimously. Put it in an order,” he said. “In the meantime, ensure that the CEC does not take any decision unilaterally.”

CJI Surya Kant said that the allegations were just newspaper reports. Senior Advocate Singh said that the ECI issued a press release and did not deny the news reports.

The Supreme Court, after hearing the petitioners, issued a notice to the Central Government and the Election Commission.

"Direct that respondent No.3 [CEC] shall not exercise the functions of Chief Election Commissioner of India pending final hearing of the present petition; direct that during such period, the business of the Commission be transacted by the unanimous decision of respondent Nos. 4 [Sukhbir Singh Sandhu] and 5 [Vivek Joshi]; and direct that any appointment to the resulting vacancy be made upon the recommendation of a Committee, including the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India," the plea stated.

The Supreme Court Bench heard a second petition against the CEC filed by advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi. The petition has sought the Constitution of an independent, high-powered Judicial Inquiry Commission or Special Investigation Team headed by a retired apex court judge to probe allegations against CEC Gyanesh Kumar.

The plea seeks an investigation that must encompass, among others, an end-to-end audit of the Election Commission databases and probe the institutional circumstances under which 13 crore names were deleted across 30 States/Union Territories under the Special Intensive Revision. It stated that Gyanesh Kumar, in light of the allegations, would be divested of any statutory or constitutional immunity; the CEC remains directly accountable under the law — subject to police investigation, evidence gathering, and regular trial proceedings as an “ordinary accused”.

Senior advocate Menaka Guruswamy, for Mr. Tripathi, said the actions of the CEC should at least be called biased. “Deletions of voters have been made in the largest democracy,” she said. “We have grown up with free and fair elections; that is not the case now. I stand by every prayer I have made in the petition.”

Related in Politics

Cyclone 'Akvan' LIVE updates: Severe cyclonic storm moves northwards; nearly 50,000 evacuated in Odisha
Politics

Cyclone 'Akvan' LIVE updates: Severe cyclonic storm moves northwards; nearly 50,000 evacuated in Odisha

Cyclone Akvan Live Updates: Follow The Hindu’s live blog for the latest updates as the severe cyclonic storm moves over the Bay of Bengal, with landfall expected along the Andhra Pradesh-Odisha coast by November 20. Get the latest updates on cyclone preparedness and evacuation me

The Hindu19 Nov
Census 2027: ‘Other’ religions list made predictive text, over 200 entries from earlier list dropped
Politics

Census 2027: ‘Other’ religions list made predictive text, over 200 entries from earlier list dropped

Census 2027 shows predictive text for “Other” religions with 76 entries after dropping over 200 previously listed options, sparking integrity concerns.

The Hindu19 Nov
BJP turns to Mathura temple issue amid cadre unease, allies’ pressure
Politics

BJP turns to Mathura temple issue amid cadre unease, allies’ pressure

BJP shifts focus to Mathura Krishna temple amid cadre unease and alliance seat-sharing pressures ahead of UP polls.

The Hindu19 Nov
Why Ukraine keeps targeting the Kerch Bridge
Politics

Why Ukraine keeps targeting the Kerch Bridge

Ukraine targets the Kerch Bridge repeatedly, highlighting strategic symbolism and ongoing impact on Russia’s supply routes and Crimea relations.

The Hindu19 Nov
Why has the INDIA bloc posed 48 questions to the Election Commission over SIR?
Politics

Why has the INDIA bloc posed 48 questions to the Election Commission over SIR?

India bloc seeks transparency on Election Commission's SIR decisions by demanding 48 interrogatories to reveal internal approval, procedure, and records.

The Hindu19 Nov
UEF, IIT-M join hands for Tamil Nadu Growth Conclave 2026; focus on 10 key sectors
Politics

UEF, IIT-M join hands for Tamil Nadu Growth Conclave 2026; focus on 10 key sectors

UEF and IIT-M join for Tamil Nadu Growth Conclave 2026, spotlighting 10 key sectors to boost the state's economy and innovation.

The Hindu18 Nov

Latest Across Vijaya Chronicle

Actor Dream Star Mayur Patel
Cinema

Happy Birthday Dream star Mayur Patel: A Look at the Kannada Actor’s Journey

Wishing versatile Kannada actor and filmmaker Mayur Patel a very happy birthday as we look back at his memorable journey in Sandalwood, from Mani to Mango Pachcha.

Ankith Reddy19 Nov
PM Modi pays tribute to former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi on her birth anniversary
Crime

PM Modi pays tribute to former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi on her birth anniversary

Indira Gandhi, India's first woman Prime Minister, was born on November 19, 1917, in Allahabad, now Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh. | India News

Hindustan Times19 Nov
Filmmaker Bharatbala reunites with AR Rahman for father-daughter drama ‘Banaras’
Cinema

Filmmaker Bharatbala reunites with AR Rahman for father-daughter drama ‘Banaras’

Director Bharatbala is set to return to feature filmmaking with his upcoming film, Banaras, which has music by AR Rahman, the makers announced recently.

The Hindu — Cinema19 Nov
Keeping foreign nationals in detention centres after granting bail defeats its purpose: Delhi HC
Crime

Keeping foreign nationals in detention centres after granting bail defeats its purpose: Delhi HC

The high court bench held that such grant of bail does not legalise any foreign national's continued stay in India or operate as a substitute for a valid visa. | India News

Hindustan Times19 Nov
'India playing a whole new game': Modi invokes GTA 6 to highlight how India has transformed since the last game
Crime

'India playing a whole new game': Modi invokes GTA 6 to highlight how India has transformed since the last game

Modi used the slides to draw a comparison in the development works India has witnessed since the release of the fifth edition of the GTA in 2013. | India News

Hindustan Times19 Nov
2 retired officials depose in 2007 Bengaluru land release case against Kumaraswamy
Crime

2 retired officials depose in 2007 Bengaluru land release case against Kumaraswamy

Shameem Bhanu and Jothi Ramalingam, both retired as additional chief secretaries, deposed before the special court for MPs and MLAs on November 16 | India News

Hindustan Times19 Nov