Karnataka HC directs government to consider offering alternative job to police constable selectee disabled during delay in getting appointment order
Karnataka HC orders government to consider a suitable alternative job for a disabled constable selectee due to appointment delay and accident.
The Bench directed the government to consider him for appointment to a suitable desk job like second division assistant, assistant writer, junior data entry operator, or any other equivalent administrative post.
Published - November 17, 2026 06:54 pm IST - Bengaluru
On November 30, 2024, while travelling to Raichur, he met with a serious road accident following which his right leg was amputated. | Image for representational purposes | Photo Credit: GORODENKOFF
In a rare and unique instance, the High Court of Karnataka has directed the State government to meaningfully consider offering an alternative government job to a 28-year-old man who lost his right limb in a road accident while awaiting appointment as a civil police constable, noting that the mishap occurred during a delay of over two years in issuing his appointment order despite a tribunal’s direction.
A Division Bench comprising Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni allowed a petition filed by Shivakumar Hiremath of Bagalkot district and set aside the June 18, 2026, order of the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal (KSAT), which had rejected his request for an alternative appointment.
The Bench directed the government to consider him for appointment to a suitable desk job like second division assistant, assistant writer, junior data entry operator, or any other equivalent administrative post, commensurate with his educational qualification, the cadre to which he was originally selected and his present physical capacity.
Mr. Hiremath had participated in the 2019 recruitment process for civil police constables in Bengaluru city. He possessed a three-year diploma, which had been recognised as equivalent to a pre-university course for recruitment purposes. Although his name figured in the final selection list, the authorities did not issue appointment orders to him and several other selected candidates because of disputes concerning the equivalence of educational qualification.
He and several other candidates approached the KSAT, which, on September 21, 2023, upheld equivalence of qualification in terms of the government’s rules, and directed the authorities to issue appointment letters to them within four months.
However, as the government failed to implement the KSAT’s order within the stipulated period, the Mr. Hiremath and other candidates initiated contempt proceedings before the tribunal in 2024. The Police Department issued an appointment order to Mr. Hiremath on January 1, 2025, directing him to report for duty on January 9.
In the meantime, tragedy struck. On November 30, 2024, while travelling to Raichur, he met with a serious road accident following which his right leg was amputated. After being informed about his disability, the department refused his plea for the alternative post.
Terming it as an extraordinary tale of administrative apathy visited upon an unfortunate selectee, the Bench said the petitioner “stands at the crossroads of two misfortunes: one inflicted by fate and the other occasioned by administrative inaction. The former has deprived him of a limb; the latter has deprived him of the timely opportunity to enter the public service”.
“An extraordinary circumstance may warrant an extraordinary consideration, provided the remedy remains anchored to the Constitution and the governing law. A one-off situation may call for a one-off solution; not as an exception to the rule of law, but as an exercise in ensuring that the rule of law does not lose its human purpose,” the Bench said.
To now tell the petitioner that he cannot be appointed because he no longer satisfies the physical standards, without even examining the possibility of an alternative suitable appointment, would be to permit the consequences of administrative delay to fall entirely upon the shoulders of the selectee, who had done no wrong, said the Bench while pointing that though he cannot be appointed as a constable now, the government should not remain indifferent to the possibility of restoring to him an opportunity for livelihood, consistent with law.
Published - November 17, 2026 06:54 pm IST
Terms & conditions | Institutional Subscriber
Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.
We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.










