LiveSaturday · 14 November 2026Vol. VIII · No. 318
Bangalore
25°C · Overcast25°C
Sat, 14 Nov
Latest
Crime

SC plea seeks recall of CEC law order over justice Sharma’s son’s ECI role

A plea in the Supreme Court seeks recall of its September 23 order on the CEC law, citing Justice Satish Chandra Sharma’s son’s role as ECI counsel | India News

SC plea seeks recall of CEC law order over justice Sharma’s son’s ECI role

A plea in the Supreme Court seeks recall of its September 23 order on the CEC law, citing Justice Satish Chandra Sharma’s son’s role as ECI counsel

An application was filed in the Supreme Court seeking recall of its September 23 order referring the challenge to the 2023 law governing the appointment of the chief election commissioner and election commissioners to a Constitution bench, citing concerns over justice Satish Chandra Sharma’s son appearing for the Election Commission of India (ECI).

The application was filed by Naman Sherstra, who is one of the petitioners who has challenged the validity of the CEC & ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023, on the ground that one of the judges who heard the matter — Justice Satish Chandra Sharma — ought to have recused himself as his son appears for the ECI before the Madhya Pradesh high court.

On September 23, a bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma gave a split verdict on whether the 2023 law should be referred to a Constitution bench. While Justice Datta was of the view that the need does not arise as the challenge to the Act can be considered based on the settled principles laid down by earlier judgments, Justice Sharma held a different view. He said that substantial questions on the interpretation of the Constitution arise in the matter and under Article 145(3), the same should be heard by a bench of at least five judges of the Supreme Court. The two judges passed a common order placing the matter before the CJI for referring the petitions to a Constitution bench.

The application categorically states that the matter was heard by the bench of Justices Datta and Sharma on five occasions. On none of the occasions did Justice Sharma disclose this fact or seek recusal on this ground. Sherstra stated that the fact about Justice Sharma’s son being engaged as ECI counsel became known from news reports that surfaced two days after the September 23 order.

It sought recall of the order stating, “The question is whether the established circumstances, viewed objectively, give rise to a reasonable apprehension concerning impartiality.” However, the application does not seek recall of Justice Datta’s separate opinion.

The present application is the second plea for recall. A curative petition was filed on Tuesday by Congress leader Jaya Thakur, also a petitioner in the present batch challenging the validity of the 2023 law. The curative plea sought recall on the ground of a “reasonable likelihood of bias,” based on the same fact linking Justice Sharma’s son to the ECI.

But Sherstra’s application categorically states that Justice Sharma did not disclose the fact of his son’s association with the ECI when the matter was heard on five occasions.

It said, “The petitioners state on record that the engagement of justice Satish Chandra Sharma’s son as the standing counsel for the ECI before the Madhya Pradesh High Court was not disclosed to the parties by justice Sharma at any point in time during the five hearings in the matter.”

The present batch of petitions was heard by the bench of Justices Datta and Sharma on five occasions — May 6, May 7, May 14, May 27 and July 30. It was on July 30 that orders were reserved on the issue of whether the petitions should be heard by a Constitution bench of five judges.

The plea for recall clarified, “The present application does not impute actual bias, motive or want of good faith to the judge concerned…if this court finds the objection well-founded, (there be) fresh consideration of the question of reference by an appropriate bench constituted by the CJI.”

It referred to the Restatement of Values of Judicial Life, adopted by the Full Court of the Supreme Court in 1997, which begins with the principle that justice must not merely be done but must also be seen to be done, and requires the conduct of the higher judiciary to reaffirm public faith and impartiality.

Going by this principle, the application said that the judge ought to have disclosed the fact of his son’s engagement to the parties appearing in the matter. This fact assumes relevance, Sreshtra said, as Justice Sharma’s son was appointed as the standing counsel for the ECI before the high court on July 10, 2024, after the appointment of the present CEC Gyanesh Kumar and one of the election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, on March 14, 2024.

If this fact was earlier known to them, they would have requested Justice Sharma’s recusal, the plea stated, while adding, “The absence of disclosure deprived the petitioners of an opportunity to raise that request before the opinions and order dated September 23 were pronounced.”

Related in Crime

Amid Vidarbha drought, Gadkari pitches for MOIL and WCL mine water use for agricultural purposes
Crime

Amid Vidarbha drought, Gadkari pitches for MOIL and WCL mine water use for agricultural purposes

Amid Vidarbha drought, Gadkari pitches for MOIL and WCL mine water use for agricultural purposes | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
Pakistan minister likely to visit India between Nov 20-22 for SCO dialogue
Crime

Pakistan minister likely to visit India between Nov 20-22 for SCO dialogue

If Musadik Masood Malik visits India, this could be a Pakistani minister’s first visit to the neighouring country in more than three years. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
US went easy on Pakistan’s military for years, says Blinken at HT Leadership Summit
Crime

US went easy on Pakistan’s military for years, says Blinken at HT Leadership Summit

Blinken drew a sharp line between the two relationships. India, he said, was a global force, while the relationship with Pakistan “has been regional”. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
US ties with India, Pakistan different in nature: Antony Blinken at HTLS 2026
Crime

US ties with India, Pakistan different in nature: Antony Blinken at HTLS 2026

Antony Blinken's remarks came against the backdrop of perceived closeness between President Donald Trump's administration and the Pakistani leadership | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
India-US ties ‘essential’ to this century, but Washington must not expect India to follow it: Former Secretary of State Antony Blinken at HTLS
Crime

India-US ties ‘essential’ to this century, but Washington must not expect India to follow it: Former Secretary of State Antony Blinken at HTLS

Blinken said India and the US had been “estranged democracies for 50 years”. This changed over the next 25 years, starting towards the end of the Clinton admin. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov
'Turbulence world is going through could last a few years': S Jaishankar at HTLS 2026
Crime

'Turbulence world is going through could last a few years': S Jaishankar at HTLS 2026

Speaking at HTLS 2026, Jaishankar said the world order today was navigating stormy seas amid multiple conflicts, frictions and uncertainties. | India News

Hindustan Times14 Nov

Latest Across Vijaya Chronicle

Bihar Police identify over one lakh mule accounts across 38 districts
Politics

Bihar Police identify over one lakh mule accounts across 38 districts

Bihar Police uncover over 1 lakh mule bank accounts across 38 districts amid 47k Bihar and 569k national cybercrime complaints in Sept-Oct.

The Hindu14 Nov
Hubballi to host bodybuilding championship in February
Politics

Hubballi to host bodybuilding championship in February

Hubballi hosts February bodybuilding championships Mr. & Ms. Karnataka and Twin City, featuring 600 participants across 36 categories with ₹3 lakh prizes.

The Hindu14 Nov
Family of each deceased in minibus-truck collision to get ₹9 lakh ex gratia: Assam CM
Politics

Family of each deceased in minibus-truck collision to get ₹9 lakh ex gratia: Assam CM

Assam will give ₹9 lakh ex gratia to the family of each of the 26 people killed in the Kaziranga minibus-truck collision, the Chief Minister said.

The Hindu14 Nov
Jr NTR announces his next with Anil Ravipudi
Cinema

Jr NTR announces his next with Anil Ravipudi

Telugu superstar Jr NTR has announced his next film with Anil Ravipudi. Taking to social media on Saturday, NTR shared a photo with Anil to confirm their collaboration, which he called to be a “laugh riot”.

The Hindu — Cinema14 Nov
Pakistani Minister to visit India for the first time in three years, as SCO meets
Politics

Pakistani Minister to visit India for the first time in three years, as SCO meets

Pakistan’s Climate Minister to visit India for SCO Civilizational Dialogue, first ministerial trip in over three years amid tense ties.

The Hindu14 Nov
HYDRAA to take up stepwell restorations to help water conservation measures in Hyderabad
Politics

HYDRAA to take up stepwell restorations to help water conservation measures in Hyderabad

HYDRAA expands to stepwell restoration in Telangana, integrating SOPs with lake conservation to boost groundwater and water security amid El Niño.

The Hindu14 Nov